Cooling tower repairs and the most common faults

Repairing cooling towers centres on four assemblies: the mechanical equipment, the fill, the drift eliminator and the water distribution system. Almost every fault shows up the same way, as a cold water temperature higher than expected, but the cause and the fix are different in each case. One of these faults also has legal implications, because Spain’s Royal Decree 487/2022 limits drift losses to less than 0.002% of the circulating water flow.

Repairing a cooling tower means restoring the component that has failed or deteriorated to its design conditions, either by refurbishing it or by replacing it. It differs from preventive maintenance in that it deals with a fault that is already present, and from revamping in that it does not renew the whole unit.

Refurbishments and improvements in cooling towers

Mechanical equipment faults in a cooling tower

The motor-fan assembly and its drive are the components that require the most interventions, because they run continuously in a humid environment. Typical faults are bearing wear, fan imbalance caused by dirt or damaged blades, deterioration of the drive and corrosion of the motor base.

The usual symptoms are vibration, abnormal noise, unusual power consumption or motor protection trips. It is worth acting early, as sustained vibration eventually damages the motor base and the anchorages.

When the motor is replaced, it is worth reviewing its protection against moisture. In recent projects we have supplied tropicalised motors with a PTC thermistor and an anti-condensation heater, which prevents condensation inside the motor. Permanent magnet synchronous motors (PMSM) also do away with transmissions and gearboxes, two of the most common wear points, and can reduce energy consumption by up to 30% compared with conventional motors.

Control also affects the service life of the assembly. When renewing a tower for a foundry in Cantabria, we fitted the Torraval Control System, which adjusts fan speed to the ambient temperature and delivers up to 20% energy savings with less wear on components.

Fill faults and loss of cooling capacity

Fill fails through fouling or deformation, and in both cases the tower cools less without triggering any alarm. Scale, sludge and biofilm reduce the heat exchange surface between water and air. Deformation occurs when the water exceeds the temperature the material can withstand.

The symptom is a gradual rise in the cold water temperature, often accompanied by higher fan consumption to compensate. Because it is gradual, it usually goes unnoticed until it affects the process.

If the fouling is superficial, cleaning can restore performance. When the fill pack is clogged or deformed, the repair means replacing it, and that is the time to check whether the type of fill was the right one.

Water with a high suspended solids content clogs film fill in a short time, so it is advisable to switch to splash fill. This is the solution we applied at a steel and metallurgical plant in Gijón and at a foundry in Cantabria, the latter with polypropylene angle profiles that withstand temperatures of up to 80 °C, arranged in a staggered pattern to prevent clogging.

The material also matters. As a general rule, we use PVC for water up to 65 °C and polypropylene for higher temperatures. You can see the options on our page of fill for cooling towers.

Drift eliminator faults

The drift eliminator fails when its panels break, become fouled or are poorly seated, leaving gaps through which the air carries water out of the tower. It is an inconspicuous fault, but it has two direct consequences: water is lost and aerosol emissions increase.

This second effect makes it a priority repair. Spain’s Royal Decree 487/2022 on the prevention and control of legionellosis requires, in its Annex III, high-efficiency drift eliminators with a drift rate below 0.002% of the circulating water flow. The previous limit, set by Royal Decree 865/2003, was 0.05%, that is, 25 times higher.

The symptoms are visible droplet carry-over in the air discharge, wet surfaces around the unit and higher make-up water consumption than usual.

The repair consists of replacing the damaged panels and checking that the assembly covers the entire cross-section without gaps. The high-efficiency drift eliminators we install keep drift losses below 0.002% of the recirculating flow, in line with that requirement and with the UNE 100030:2017 standard.

Water distribution system faults

The distribution system fails mainly through clogging of nozzles, pipes and channels. Contaminants in the water, airborne dust, salts and microorganisms form sludge that prevents the water from being spread evenly over the fill.

The consequences follow one another. First, distribution becomes uneven and the channels can overflow. Then the nozzles clog and the dispersing plates end up breaking, so the water falls directly onto the fill and damages it.

That is why an unrepaired distribution fault ends up turning into a fill fault, which is more costly. Dry areas in the fill pack and concentrated jets are the signal to intervene.

The repair combines cleaning pipes and channels with replacing damaged nozzles and plates. It is advisable to inspect the fill underneath before considering the job finished.

Design affects how often these faults occur. With sediment-laden water, open channels make access and cleaning easier, and anti-clogging nozzles reduce incidents. You will find the replacement parts on our distribution systems page.

Repair, revamp or replace the tower

A repair solves the failure of a specific component. When several faults coincide in the same unit, the right intervention is usually revamping, which renews the internal and external components together to restore the tower’s original performance and adapt it to new requirements.

In the comprehensive revamping of a small cooling tower, the work consisted, in this order, of replacing the drift eliminator, cleaning the basin, refurbishing and painting the motor base, replacing the motor shims, installing a new motor with stainless steel fasteners and fitting a new fan assembly.

Full replacement is reserved for units that have reached the end of their service life. The foundry in Cantabria mentioned above replaced a forced draft tower installed in 1993, after more than 30 years in service, with a current model of the same type featuring improvements in efficiency, accessibility and control.

Technical service for cooling tower repair

At Torraval we repair cooling towers with our own teams and original manufacturer spare parts. We have been designing and manufacturing this equipment for more than 55 years, we are part of the MITA group and we work under ISO 9001 and ISO 14001 certification.

Our service capacity has been strengthened in recent years. The acquisition of Intercal added a team specialised in the installation, repair and maintenance of cooling towers and evaporative condensers.

The Huelva workshop shortens response times for maintenance and repair at installations in Andalusia and the surrounding area. In Argentina, Montajes Revenga acts as our official technical service.

If your tower has lost performance or shows any of the symptoms described, contact our technical team and we will assess what intervention it needs.


 

Contact us

In case you need further information about our products or services, do not hesitate to contact us by filling in the form.

Or call us at: 944 520 000

    This information will not be used for advertising purposes. We will only use your data to respond to your query.



    Proyectos destacados y noticias

    Solicita información

    Si necesitas más información sobre nuestros productos o servicios, no dudes en contactar con nosotros a través del formulario.

    O si lo prefieres, llámanos al:

    94 452 00 00

      Esta información no se utilizará con fines publicitarios. Únicamente utilizaremos sus datos para responder a su consulta.



      2023 © Copyright. Todos los derechos reservados

      Desarrollado por Posik Marketing Digital